How to Choose the Right Espresso Machine or the Coffee Maker? Expert's Blog.

Original Bialetti vs. Cheap Chinese Stainless Steel Moka Pot. Tested

Comments: 10↓ specifications & manual ↓

Bialetti is a company that invented moka pots. However, today many other brands offer Italian stove top coffee makers for 2 or even 3 times lower price. Is there any real difference between them except the famous ‘little man with the mustache’ logo, which Bialetti proudly put on its models? (Spoiler: yes)

I decided to compare stainless steel versions, since my new kitchen is equipped with a induction stove (classic aluminium moka pots like Moka Express or Brikka can’t work with it). I choose a Bialetti Venus by Bialetti (‘Made in India according to Bialetti’s quality standarts’ was written on the box) and a similar moka pot by some unknown brand from China (almost 3 times cheaper). Both are for 4 cups, which equals to 160ml. Here they are:

Bialetti Venus vs Cheap Chinese Moka Pot: Tested and Compared

The Chinese moka pot that I bought is sold under different names in different countries. Usually it costs less than Bialetti’s one:

In the States you may find it in stock as a Stovetop Espresso by Túasia, AMFOCUS Stovetop Espresso Maker or VonShef Stovetop Espresso Coffee Maker. Similar Inox moka pots are sold also by Primula, BEMINH, Mixpresso Coffee, WeHome, MAYMII, MODIN and Maggift brands.

All these models as I assume are OEM manufactured products. The “original” noname Chinese coffee maker is available on Aliexpress.

Exactly the same model could be found in the UK. Here it is known as 6-Cup Espresso Coffee Maker by Kurtzy (ATWFS, Linaatales, Tooltime, KING HOFF and Yosoo sell identical stainless steel pot as well). On the German market and in other European countries it is known as Generic Moka Espressokocher, Cuigu Edelstahl Moka Pot, HuntGold or UniqueHeart. In Asia (Indonesia as an example) they don’t bother to invent brand names and sell it just as namless stainless steel moka.

If you will search for stainless steel moka pot on your local Amazon, then likely you will find more clones. They all look the same and, based on reviews anaysis, they all have similiar drawbacks, which I found in my specimen as well.

So let’s investigate the differences between cheap Chinese moka pot made of steel vs original Bialetti Venus. I will not describe the unboxing process (though Bialetti packaging was better) and focus on the materials, construction, coffee taste and temperature:

1. Materials used

Both coffee makers are made of stainless steel. However the thickness of the metal is different, Chinese one definetly has more slim edges (hereinafter on photos the Bialetti is on left while the Chinese one is on right):

Moka Por Steel Thickness

The fact that Bialetti uses a lot more metal while producing their stove top espresso makers is also proven by the weight. According to my kitchen scale it’s 544 grams (19.2 ounces) in the case of Bialetti vs 330 grams (11.6 ounces) in the case of its counterpart. Both measurements are made without boxes:

Weights

Different weight changes the brewing procces, by the way. I will describe it below.

❕ The main thing, that dissapointed me was the weirdly coated bottom section in Chinese moka pot. While the Bialetti has a equaly shiny polished steel both outside and inside, the bottom chamber of the second coffee maker has a layer of some strange material:

Inner Surface - strange coating

I made a brief analysis of reviews and customer photos of all above mentioned clones (Primula, AMFOCUS, VonShef , MODIN, Maggift etc). Other people report the same, so it’s not just because my specimen was defected.

Some people assume that it’s unbrushed steel. However, mainly due the specific smell (this fact itself could be listed in cons) I think that they put a layer of some non-stick coating inside. Either because it’s cheaper than polishing it from inside or because they use less chromium/nickel in the alloy (they are needed to make the metal stainless). That’s why inner parts that are constantly in contact with water have to be covered by some protective surface in order not to corrode.

Anyway, the reason why Chinese-made moka pot has this covering is not so important. What important is that there is some strange smelly thing inside, not just the shiny polished steel.

The same coating, but in less amount, could be noticed in the upper chamber as well. See photo below:

2. Construction

Generally the construction and design of both stove top makers are eqaul. Chinese one even has the identical funnel and gasket:

identical funnels and gaskets of Bialetti Venus and Cheap Chinese moka pot

However, what is really terrible and annoying (even more than strange smelly internal surface) is the built quality and the plastic handle combined with the lid opener. Let me show it in details:

My Chinese moka pot (as well as Primula, ATWFS, Kurtzy and most of other clones, which apparently are made using the same technical process) has unfinished welding seam on the upper part that is visible from inside. The same defect was reported by other users, for example, you can notice this defect even on relatively well-rated model by VonShef (check on amazon):

welding seam

Needless to say that original Bialetti Venus doesn’t have such “scar”:

no welding seam on bialetti venus

The flimsy plastic part, which is used as a handle and the opener for the upper lid on Chinese models, have folowwing drawbacks:

  • It’s small and it’s uncomfortable to handle, morover, when you will try to use it as a lid opener, your thimb will likely touch the hot metal (at least you are not a child with small fingers)
  • It’s attached with one(!) screw. No surpise, that users often report that the handle come off quickly.
  • Finally the lid moves and sounds like a door of 40 y.o. Renault compared to any modern car:

My last observation is about emergency valve that is located one the side of the bottom chamber and that is used to lower the pressure if the funnel would be clogged. They are different:

emergency-valves-compared

Bialetti uses a special anti-scale valve (on the left). That is how it’s described in the manual:

The Bialetti inspection valve is a patented valve, which has been designed to guarantee the use of the coffee maker in complete safety. Using the coffee maker with drinking water entails the risk of formation of lime scale in the hole of the safety valve, causing the clogging of the valve itself and the malfunctioning of the product.
With the Bialetti inspection valve, it is very simple to avoid clogging arising from lime scale: just move the small piston coming out of the valve along its axis when washing the coffee maker.

3. Taste and Temperature

As I mentioned above the fact that Chinese has thinner metal body affects the brewing proccess. Bialetti’s upper chamber stays cools longer, while all parts of Chinese coffee maker becomes hot very soon. That means that temperature of extraction is higher on Chinese one. It’s generally condidered to be bad for the coffee taste (because it may become bitter), however it’s better for lovers of hot coffee.

Here are photos of coffee temperature measurement in Bialetti Venus and in ATWFS moka pot just after brewing on gas cooker (photos kindly provided by my reader kroleg-m):

Coffee in Bialetti Venus is 73°C. Chinese Moka pot makes 86°C

I NEED your opinion. Please rate my review:

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (2 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Loading...

 

Author: Dmitriy Yurchenko

27/08/2018

Have any questions? Please ask in comments below!

Have you bought this coffee machine? Leave a review!

10 comments:

  1. We have both Bialetti and Chinese. The Bialetti is much better built. The bottom of the Chinese one has blown into a dome which means it rocks on any flat surface , such as our flat cooker plates. So now useless.

    Paul

    31 Aug 18 at 8:27 am

    Reply

  2. What about other Italian moka pot producer like Pedrini? Can you compare Bialetti and Pedrini? I want to know since Pedrini is cheaper than Bialetti.

    Ranu

    5 Apr 19 at 8:38 am

    Reply

    • Hi, Ranu. Pedrini produces its moka pots in China, some of Bialetti’s moka pots are made in Italy (uncolored Moka Express and some limited series), others in Romania (all aluminium models) or India (all stainless steel models). In China they made only Junior Express (sub brand of Bialetti) and Kitty Nero. Plus Pedrino has a simple emergency valve, while Bialetti has improved one, which is more resistant to scale (but, honestly, it’s important only if you have very hard water). Nevertheless, Pedrini pots are still good, no smells or bad materials used like in some cheap Chinese coffee makers.

      So… If you need just a decent moka pot and don’t want to pay extra for the brand, for the classical design and for the proudly printed words “Made in Italy”. Then you may go with Pedrini 🙂

      P. S. You can check also Top Moka – another Italian brand with cheaper mokas. They have special shape of the bottom parts, which is claimed to heat the water faster. But I never tested it personally. And they still make it in Italy.

      Dmitriy

      5 Apr 19 at 2:47 pm

      Reply

      • I see.. thanks for the detailed answer. What about the Bialetti Break? I notice that it’s the cheapest series from Bialetti. Is it made in China as well?

        Ranu

        8 Apr 19 at 12:49 pm

        Reply

        • It is made in Romania. At least one year ago it was like that, unlikely that something changed.

          Dmitriy

          8 Apr 19 at 4:27 pm

          Reply

          • Dmitry, thanks for the answer. I just bought Pedrini 3 cups today. And like you wrote, it was made in China. However, I liked it. Previously, I bought a cheap moka pot that was made in Korea. Pedrini looks better than the cheap one. You were right. No smells and it has better materials.

            Ranu

            9 Apr 19 at 4:08 pm

            Reply

  3. Thanks for detailed review. Always wondered why my cheap noname chinese moka pot makes so bitter coffee, and tried to do something about it, getting it off the stove sooner than steam would come out. Turns out, I’d better change it at all. (so I did, and chose espresso maker). But, if I ever need moka, now I know what to buy.

    Asviar

    18 Apr 19 at 3:56 pm

    Reply

  4. Best comparison article I’ve read so far. Can you please suggest any other “made in Italy” descent brands, made of stainless steel, that can be found on Amazon? The top moka you mentioned in another answer, isn’t stainless steel

    Streetlight

    21 May 19 at 11:06 am

    Reply

    • I’m afraid that the only truly “made in Italy” stainless steel moka pots are by Alessi. By the way, Alessi was a grandson of Mr. Bialetti, so these companies have strong family ties 🙂 The only problem is that Alessi’s moka pots are pricey, because they are specialized on top-notch coffee makers designed by famous artists. But it’s 100% Italian. They have three series of steel moka pots:
      Model 9090: https://amzn.to/2Hu5LDh https://amzn.to/2M00bwr
      La Cupola: https://amzn.to/30BQOqi
      La Conica: https://amzn.to/2VE79qo

      P. S. If you are also considering decent Italian brands, but with steel production in China (except Bialetti) then you can check Pedrini https://amzn.to/2JOTyum I would trust this brands, however, they also moved factories outside Italy.

      Dmitriy

      21 May 19 at 12:34 pm

      Reply

Have some doubts which model to choose? Ask me!

Leave a Reply to Paul Cancel reply