How to Choose the Right Coffee Machine or the Coffee Maker? Expert's Blog.

How to Choose the Right Coffee Machine or the Right Coffee Maker?

My independent advices are based on 6 years of experience in coffee machines sales. 2 comments

When it comes to choosing a coffee maker or coffee machine for your home, it’s important to ask yourself ten main questions in order to make a smart buy. In my blog, I will try give a step-by-step guide and make detailed reviews of most popular models.

#1. The first question is do you a need coffee maker or machine in the first place?

The difference is that you don’t have to spend your time on bean-to-cup coffee machines to prepare your coffee, you just have to press the button. That’s why they are more expensive than coffeemakers, the cheapest and the simplest models such as Philips Xsmall HD8645 (HD8743 in England), Krups EA81 Pisa, or Delonghi ESAM 3300 Magnifica. That’s the lowest prices for automatically made black coffee. If you want an automated cappuccino, you should pay at least at least twice more.

Coffee makers will need your participation to prepare a cup: you are going to have to grind coffee beans, put it inside a maker, manually control the process, and then clean it. However, they are way cheaper:

  • Espresso machines for making espresso or cappuccino with a manual cappuccinator (called ‘pannarello’) such as Delonghi EC155 or Delonghi ECP3420 are the cheapest. More expensive models like Delonghi ECO311 or Gaggia Style are basically the same inside, only their design vary.  Those prices are for models with pumps to brew strong espresso. Models without a pump give only 2-3 bar pressure (comparing to 15-19 bar in the previous case) and cost even less (Delonghi EC5 is the example).
  • Drip coffee makers are even more cheaper and are ideal for those of you who love only US-style black coffee (long and not strong).
  • Cheapest option for espresso lovers is moka pots that could be bought for the price of drip coffee maker (original Bialetti Moka Express) or even less (chineese copies of Bialetti).

As a result, we have first estimates for you to make the right choice:

I’m ok with preparing black coffee manually, spending 5-10 minutes per cup I’m ok with preparing coffee manually, but I want cappuccino/latte also I want automated black coffee I want automated black coffee AND cappuccino/latte
Starting budget

$

for a moka pot or a drip coffee maker

$$

for an espresso machine with a manual milk frother

$$$$

for super-automatic coffee machines

$$$$$

for super-automatic coffee machines with one-touch cappuccino

Examples Drip coffer maker and moka pot by Bialetti

  • In US: Bialetti Moka Express. Cuisinart DCC-3200, BLACK+DECKER CM2035B, Mr. Coffee SK13.
  • In UK: Bialetti Moka Express. Delonghi ICM15210, Krups KM442D, Bosch TKA3A031.
Example photos icon of espresso machines

Coffee machine with panarello

Coffee machine with milk jar

  • In US: Saeco Philips Intelia Deluxe, DeLonghi ECAM23450SL, Jura Impressa S9, Krups Barista.
  • In UK: Philips Saeco Intelia Deluxe, DeLonghi ECAM25.462, Melitta Varianza CSP F57, Bosch Verocafe Latte.

 

Now let’s go further and ask ourselves the second important question.

#2. But isn’t it cheaper to buy a single serve coffeemaker/machine with coffee capsules?

It depends on how much coffee you drink. However, usually, it is not a smart buy, unless you want to make just one cup per day.

The standalone category is capsule coffee makers (or capsule machines, or single serve). And there is a reason why some sellers call it a ‘machine’, while others name it a ‘coffeemaker.’ From one point of view, it’s an automated machine since user has to press only one button. Nevertheless, one the other hand, it’s not so automated since you use coffee capsules, that is ground and packed in a factory.

Prices on capsule models vary. The budget is even under one hundred dollar. Examples of single serve machines are Legato Single Serve or original Nescafe Dolce Gusto (such as Genio EDG455T EX:1). Sometimes, single serve coffee makers could be 5 times more expansive, for example for the original Nespresso models that can also automatically froth the milk for your cappuccino (Latissima series).

Capsule machines are very simple to use and maintain, and they are usually very compact. However, the main disadvantage of those – is the cost of capsules. So, I can’t call it a smart choice if you or your family drinks more than 2 cups of coffee per day. Here’s why:

Cheapest $400 coffee machine: Cheapest $100 single serve maker:
~ 5,8 kg / 13 oz. of beans per year 730 capsules per year
x x
х $10 per pound (coffee beans) x $0.75 (coffeer capsules)
drawn equals sign drawn equals sign
Total = $130 Total = $547.5

 

As you can see, you will have to spend extra $400 for coffee capsules in just 1 year. In addition, since you are attached to a particular capsule system (e.g. you will have to buy only Tassimo pods for Bosch Tassimo capsule makers) you really have no choice of coffee. Moreover, of course, fresh ground good coffee is tastier than factory-made capsules. Finally, coffee pods are less environmentally friendly.

That takes us to the second conclusion

I drink less than 2 cups of black coffee a day I drink less than 2 cups of black coffee or cappuccino a day I drink two or more cups a day or I want really super fresh coffee
Starting budget

$

for an original capsule coffeemaker w/o milk frother

$$

for an original capsule coffeemaker with an automated cappuccino system

Consider buying a real automated coffee machine or a manual coffee maker and continue reading further.
Examples

 

#3. Espresso or US long coffee?

Since my blog is international, I should consider that question. Because in Americas people usually prefer a big cup of not so strong coffee. In Europe, we call it ‘Americano’. Nevertheless, as for ourselves, we prefer espresso and espresso-based drinks which are stronger and come in smaller portions.

All major coffee machine producers such as Philips/Saeco/Gaggia (it’s the same company now), Delonghi, Jura, Melitta, and KRUPS are initially European. In addition, their primary aim was to design an espresso machine. Sure, you can add hot water from the steam wand to espresso and make a cup standard of US style coffee. That’s how Americano is classically prepared in Italy. However, the result is little bit different from traditional filter coffee.

Still there are models that have an additional function to imitate the process of brewing filter coffee on the European market. Usually, special mode is used. It reduces the pressure from standard 15 bar for espresso to 2-3 bars. Both Saeco/Philips (they call the needed function ‘coffee switch’) and DeLonghi (they call it ‘long’) have such models. In the UK, the price starts from £400 and examples are DeLonghi’s ETAM 29.510 Autentica or Philips 4000 series HD8847. In America, you can choose ESAM6900 PrimaDonna Exclusive or ESAM6700 PrimaDonna Avant by DeLonghi.

In addition, producers have special class of the so-called grind-and-brew coffee machines. Which are indeed automated machines (remember the criteria of one-touch and coffee beans use) and prepare traditional filter coffee exactly how it should be prepared. Examples are Philips Grind & Brew HD7766 or 7765, Cuisinart DGB-650BC, Black & Decker CM5000 Mill and Brew.

All of the above leads us to the next conclusion:

I drink only US style coffee and I want it to be automatically made from beans I drink only US style coffee and I’m ok with doing it manually I drink only US style coffee, but my significant other loves cappuccino. Both should be automated. No, I need an espresso and/or cappuccino
Starting budget

$$

Your choice is grind&brew.

$

for a drip coffee maker. Plus extra money for a good burr grinder if you want your coffee fresh

 

$$$$$

for super-automatic coffee machines with both one-touch cappuccino and US style coffee functions

continue reading further
Examples

 

Ok. That’s enough for today. I will continue writing this article later.

Автор: Dmitriy

08/01/2017

Ask me!

2 комментария:

  1. I’m thinking of buying a one-touch machine, though I can see the different functions and options from different brands and specific models, the problem, is that enough to have a good tasting coffee?

    and what do you recommend? the one-touch from Saeco GranBaristo Avanti Super-automatic or it’s equivalent from Delonghi “Primadonna Elite ECAM 650.75.MS”

    Abdulaziz Al-Shareedah

    20 Jan 18 at 8:40 am

    Reply

    • I would try to briefly name main distinctions and key features.

      Saeco GranBaristo Avanti. This models is equipped with larger brewing unit (all other machines by Saeco, Gaggia and Philips have identical unit, gran baristo is an only exception). It can use up to 16 gramms of coffee per drinks. Delonghi – 14 gramms. The taste of espresso on Saeco is a bit more acidic, then on Delonghi.

      Both have an app for iOS/Android to control the machine, both “know” many recipes (Delonghi 14, Saeco 20), both have special mode for americano/caffe crema (brewing unit can reduce the pressure to imitate filter coffee).

      But! Delonghi can also: 1) make hot chocolate 2) make the cappuccino by original recipe (adding milk foam to espresso, not vice versa like Saeco Granbaristo do). It also have to milk frothers of two different types: manual one (if you would like to practice latte art) and automatic milk frother with foam regulator (you can set it to make higher foam or less foam). Saeco has only one frother (automatic with out foam regulator).

      To sum up, the Delonghi ECAM 650.75 is definitely more functional if compared with Granbaristo, and for the same price I would choose it.

      Dmitriy

      20 Jan 18 at 5:01 pm

      Reply

  2. Have some doubts which model to choose? Ask me!